Lobster Tails On Sale!
4.5/5 - Read Reviews - Write a Review
Capt. Tim Offers you 4 Sizes Of Cold Water Maine Lobster Tails that are SO easy to prepare!
Free Overnight Shipping And On Sale Now!
The Finest Cold Water Maine Lobsters Tails Shipped Overnight Right To Your Door!
Our Customers Say:
"We’ve love ordering from LobsterGuy! We’ve been their customers for several years now, and so we ordered again this year for Mother's Day, and for the same good, delicious reason again!
LobsterGuy’s staff are always pleasant, efficient and completely trustworthy service, and of course those yummy lobsters are the reason we keep ordering from them! We just Love LobsterGuy!"
On Occasion, We Also Stock quantities of Even Bigger 14-16 oz. 16-18 oz. and also massive 18-20 oz.Tails!
Please call us toll free @ 1-866-788-0004 for Pricing And Availability, Thanks!
sale: $22.99
4.5 out of 5 Claws (based on 4.5 Reviews)
TIM
February 25, 2020
Joanne McGinnis
January 19, 2020
Scott. C
January 14, 2020
Best Lobster Tails
We ordered these for the holidays. They arrived perfectly packed and perfect sizes! Delivered overnight without a hitch! This is by far the BEST lobster company to deal with, they even put a handwritten card in the box thanking me for my order? Who does that anymore?
We will order more again soon!
We will order more again soon!
ron rubino
July 14, 2018
best tails this side of the rio grande
way out here in far southwest Arizona . ordered tails this past Christmas for a gift for my wife shes in love with them second year buying from old capn tim , great lobster tails, good prices ,and excellent people to buy from , lookin forward to doin it again this Christmas !!!!
Irene Sabin
January 13, 2018
Best dang tails I?ve ever eaten
I was utterly floored when I coooked the tails, much less ate then . Understand, I only have access to a microwave to do any cooking (I?m a disabled vet living in a nursing home)(several strikes against successful cooking)! But, these were the easiest, most tender tails I?ve ever cooked. The shell and underbelly was incredibly tender and easy to cut, even using inadequate tools. Can?t quite get the proper tools to break down the shells! But these were unbelievable; then the taste was out of this world. I think I ate half of one without melted butter! I?m buying another order RIGHT NOW! They (and you!) are awesome! Yum!
Charles
October 12, 2017
Kathy Nagwak
October 10, 2017
Debora
January 13, 2017
D. Smith
December 30, 2016
Best Christmas Present we ever received !
Tony Muniz
December 29, 2016
Lobster Tails
I ordered four 10-12oz tails for a Christmas dinner in Florida. The tails came packed frozen in dry ice. They were spectacular. The customer service was accurate and pro-active. I will order from the Lobster Guy again and everyday. The price, quality, and service is unmatched!
Happy New Year
Tony
Happy New Year
Tony
Deb
December 18, 2016
Came through with 5 claws!
We were have a Christmas party and wanted something a little different so we ordered ten 5 oz lobster tails to go with our filet mignon. They were delicious and fresh and are ordering more for Christmas Eve. We butter poached them on the stove - amazing! Thank you!
Bradley "HITMAN" Anderson
December 14, 2016
Keep'em Come'em Captain Tim
This will be my 3rd year in a row for your Lobster Tails. Let me just say what happened my 1st year & take it from there... I ordered the pair of 12-14 oz, Lobster Tails. I wasn't thinking straight, because all I could base it on were out dated store tails or local restaurants "6 oz," sizes. I bought a 24 oz. Porterhouse for the Primary Choice. Then I opened the box from Captain Tim and ALL HELL BROKE LOOSE. I could wear just one tail on my head as a hat ! Needless to say... there was enough leftovers for my dog and 2 katz to Party with. KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK CAPTAIN TIM & ASSOCIATES. Needless to say... "I'll Be BACK".
karen walbridge
November 16, 2015
Jeff
February 18, 2015
Best of the best
Captain Tim:
I am writing from Sarasota, Florida, and judging from the Weather Channel, no lobster fishing today!
My wife and I and our two grandchildren, age 15 & 14 celebrated Valentine's Day last night with 4 beautiful tails from The Lobster Guy. For the past several years, I had been ordering from tocatchapieceofmaine, but have learned they are no longer doing retail. My internet search came up with your website, and many positive reviews. I was tremendously impressed with your customer service as well as the outstanding quality of the lobsters. I look forward to continued business and wish you and your crew well, especially through your nonsense winter.
Jeffrey S. W.
p.s. loved the neat Valentines Day card in the sand!! Perfect!
Amanda K.
February 18, 2015
Jim
January 14, 2015
Mary S.
November 28, 2014
Perfection!
I have had the pleasure of ordering from you three times now, my parent's 50th Anniversary, Memorial Day weekend, and Labor Day weekend. Each and every tail was perfect!! I am a forever customer and I sing your praises loud and clear! Thanks for making me look good!
Jim L.
June 11, 2014
GREAT TAILS!!
I served the 8-10oz tails at my annual barbeque this past weekend, and my 22 guests LOVED them!!! They were the best tails most of my guests ever had. I had a couple extra tails, and there was almost a fight over who would get the extras! Sweet, tender, and succulent almost doesn't do them justice. Packaging was excellent, and quality was superb. I will definitely be back for more. Don't even consider buying your lobster tails anywhere else but here!!
Janida
May 9, 2014
Excellent!
Just a quick note to let you know that fedex came thru and delivered my lobster tails right on time! We cooked those last evening, and I must say, those were the absolute best lobster tails any of the four of us has ever had. My sister and I trimmed them up, cut the undersides, and poached them in butter and garlic (beurre monte of sorts) until just done. Tender and flavorful, those tails were better than even the best seafood restaurants we've eaten in (lots), I will definitely be ordering more! Thank you for your excellent service, and for providing product as good as advertised.
Janida, Apple Valley, CA
Janida, Apple Valley, CA
Stan
May 9, 2014
